The
last few weeks have seen a marked increase in e-mails, which should
make me happy . . .but unfortunately they have been communications of
the most hateful sort. My writing causes some people to speak and act
in harmful, hurtful, ways I would hope they avoid in everyday
situations. I write transgressive fiction, it's all about crossing
boundaries, so that isn't necessarily surprising. It is, however,
off-putting and, at times, more than a bit scary. So, I've decided
it's time to re-run my manifesto and warn prospective readers just
what they may find between the pages.
You
might not like my writing if . . .
you
love romance - I don't write romance. Love stories, absolutely. Every
story I write has love at its center, but I don't believe in happily
ever after. In fact, I think happily ever after is the root of a lot
of discontent. Girls are raised from birth hearing a prince will
come, save all their problems and they will live happily ever after.
Of course, we all know real life isn't that easy. Relationships take
time, and work. People argue. Demands of the world intrude. The most
we can realistically expect is happy for now. When the fairy tale
doesn't pan out most are quick to discard their partner and try
another, always searching for the elusive prince, never appreciating
all the parts they enjoy.
You
might not like my writing if . . .
you
don't like strong flawed gay men. I write exclusively homoerotic
fiction. Women, when they do appear, are not a party to any of the
primary relationships. Nothing against women, don't get me wrong, but
the dynamic of two strong men together is irresistible. Unlike a
heterosexual pairing, either or both parties can choose to be
dominant or submissive, or to give or receive. The thought processes
behind these decisions shine a bright light on the inner landscape of
the characters, which is the key to all my stories. My men are
flawed, true, but aren't we all? Those flaws give us character and
provide obstacles to be surmounted. Our weaknesses make us human,
lovable, relatable. Shouldn't fictional characters be the same?
you
might not like my writing if . . .
the
darker side of sexuality scares or disgusts you. I write
transgressive fiction. Twisted power exchanges, dubious consent, rape
and even torture all make an appearance at some point in my work.
These are the pivotal moments, the contrast to the love we all search
for. Pitting the dark against the light allows my characters to see
themselves, grow and develop as people. My stories are, ultimately,
about the inner landscape of the characters, their struggle to
overcome what genetics and the world have given them to work with.
Set in wider stories, true, but this inner path is the one that
always drives the narrative.
you
might not like my writing if . . .
sex,
sex and more sex is what you crave. My sex is explicit, this is true,
but it certainly isn't continuous or gratuitous. It may be fifty
pages before the main characters get together, and another 250 before
it happens again. Too much sex for some, not enough for others, but
the right amount for the story and the characters. Every sex scene
serves a purpose, whether for good or for ill, and moves the
characters closer to understanding themselves and each other. How
they feel, what they enjoy or despise, and why, fleshes out our
understanding of the path they walk and lets us experience
vicariously things we would never want to go through ourselves.
you
might not like my writing if . . .
infidelity,
disillusionment, abandonment or multiple partners leave you cold. All
these real world occurrences are standard fodder for me. Love in the
real world is rarely simple or straightforward, why should it be so
in novels. Learning to live with such things is part of learning
acceptance and forgiveness, both of which you need in abundance to
find and hold on to love.
you
might not like my writing if . . .
stories
set in other cultures are too alien for you to relate to. Most of my
work is set in Japan, and the culture, traditions and language
feature prominently. The formality of address, sexual mores and
religious beliefs are radically different from those in the west. It
takes a willingness to submerge yourself in that culture to truly
appreciate the nuances of the characters and their interactions.
you
might not like my writing if . . .
you
are a lover of genre fiction, as I don't fall into any single genre -
not romance, not erotica, not fantasy, not thriller. It is, instead,
small yet epic, personal, erotic but not erotica, filled with love
but not romance. Difficult to read, at times and, hopefully, thought
provoking. Above all it is a journey to understanding. Darkly
different but universal. In short, demanding of the readers
attention. Hopefully it rewards those who rise to those demands. It
isn't everyone's cup of tea, and I'm okay with that. After all, I'm
not, either.
While I love the insight into what you write and, furthermore, why you write it, I feel quite strongly that you shouldn't have had to post this at all. Why, why, why, WHY can't people understand that if there is nothing nice to say, they should shut up and move on? If you're asking directly for their opinion, and they can't find anything nice to say about it (which, given the depth, clarity and beauty of your writing, I find that hard to believe), should they not just say, 'Look, it's not my cup of tea, really" and go from there? As for people who write you out of the blue to tell you they hate your stuff because it's dark/has too much/not enough sex/there are no hetero pairings/the violence is icky/how come there's no happy endings?, etc, etc, etc... to them, I can only say one thing: grow up. You will always find work you love and work you hate in this world. There's no need to lambast anyone over it. Jeeeeez.
ReplyDeleteNot liking it is fine - I know it isn't everyone's thing. Threats of death and dismemberment though . . .those pull me up short and make me contemplate getting out of this writing business altogether. There are some very sick people in this world and, for some reason, they want to reach out and touch me (and not in the good way).
ReplyDeleteI'm so very sorry that you're receiving such asinine emails. There's really no cause for that sort of reaction. It might not be their cup of tea, but to threaten to hurt you? That makes me angry.
ReplyDeleteI love your writing. It's hard for me to read sometimes, but there's such honesty in your work, it's heartbreaking and beautiful.
You get hateful emails??? Threats of death and dismemberment??? WOW, you are really pushing some buttons, honey. I guess you could look on that as something pretty impressive. But, seriously, don't ever let anyone censor you, or stop you expressing your creativity in whatever way you wish. Fuck 'em. Well...actually, no. But you know what I mean. xxxxx
ReplyDelete